Introduction
When you win a case in Ontario's Small Claims Court, you're usually entitled to recover some of your legal costs from the losing party. However, the rules governing these cost awards are complex and designed to balance fairness with access to justice. This guide explains how these rules work and why they exist.
Important Note
This guide is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Always consult with a qualified legal professional for specific legal matters.
The Two Types of Costs
Ontario's Small Claims Court divides recoverable costs into two distinct categories, each with different rules:
1. Disbursements
Out-of-pocket expenses you actually paid to pursue your case.
- • Court filing fees
- • Service costs (max $60/person)
- • Document preparation (max $200)
- • Travel and accommodation
- • Expert reports
- • Photocopying
No percentage cap applies to disbursements
2. Other Costs
Compensation for legal representation or self-representation.
- • Lawyer/paralegal fees
- • Self-representation compensation
- • Double-costs from settlement offers
- • Penalties for bad behavior
Subject to 15% cap (with exceptions)
The 15% Cap: Keeping Costs Reasonable
The Courts of Justice Act imposes a crucial limit: "costs other than disbursements" cannot exceed 15% of the amount you originally claimed. This cap serves several important purposes:
Why the 15% Cap Exists
- Access to Justice: Prevents legal costs from becoming disproportionate to the dispute value
- Predictability: Parties can estimate their maximum cost exposure before litigation
- Proportionality: Ensures the "cure isn't worse than the disease" in small disputes
Example: How the Cap Works
• You claim $10,000 and win $8,000
• Your lawyer charges $3,000 in fees
• 15% cap = $10,000 × 15% = $1,500
• Result: You can only recover $1,500 of the $3,000 lawyer fee
Settlement Offers: The Double-Costs Rule
Rule 14.07 creates powerful incentives for reasonable settlement by allowing courts to award up to double the normal costs when a party unreasonably rejects a settlement offer.
When Double-Costs Apply
All three conditions must be met:
7-Day Rule
Offer made at least 7 days before trial
Not Withdrawn
Offer remained open until trial
Better Result
Judgment was as good or better than offer
Why This Rule Exists
The double-costs rule encourages reasonable settlement behavior by:
- • Penalizing parties who unreasonably reject fair offers
- • Reducing court backlogs by encouraging settlement
- • Compensating the offering party for unnecessary trial costs
- • Creating economic pressure to seriously consider settlement offers
The 30% Cap for Double-Costs
When Rule 14.07 applies and costs are doubled, the cap increases from 15% to 30% of the amount claimed. This ensures the doubling effect isn't negated by the original cap, preserving the rule's intended consequences for unreasonable settlement rejection.
Self-Representation: Leveling the Playing Field
Recognizing that self-represented parties face unique challenges, Ontario law provides compensation for the time and inconvenience of representing yourself.
Standard Compensation
Up to $500 for inconvenience and expense
- • Time spent preparing case
- • Lost work time for court appearances
- • Stress and inconvenience
- • Learning legal procedures
With Settlement Success
Up to $1,500 when Rule 14.07 applies
- • Recognizes additional trial preparation
- • Compensates for rejected settlement efforts
- • Encourages reasonable settlement offers
- • Maintains access to justice
Policy Rationale
Self-representation compensation acknowledges that while people have the right to represent themselves, doing so requires significant time, effort, and often results in lost income. This compensation helps ensure that lack of legal representation doesn't become a barrier to accessing justice.
Penalties for Unreasonable Behavior
Courts have the power to impose additional penalties and lift the 15% cap when a party behaves unreasonably during litigation.
What Constitutes Unreasonable Behavior
- • Frivolous or vexatious claims
- • Refusing reasonable settlement offers
- • Causing unnecessary delays
- • Abusing court processes
- • Making false allegations
- • Failing to comply with court orders
- • Pursuing clearly hopeless cases
- • Unnecessarily complicating proceedings
Consequences
When unreasonable behavior is found, courts can:
- • Award additional penalty amounts
- • Lift the 15% cap entirely
- • Order full indemnity costs
- • Require immediate payment
The Balance
This power serves as both a deterrent and a remedy. It protects the court system from abuse while ensuring that parties who act reasonably aren't penalized by those who don't. The threat of uncapped costs encourages all parties to approach litigation responsibly.
Practical Tips for Litigants
Before You Sue
- • Calculate the 15% cap on your claim
- • Consider whether legal fees are worth it
- • Keep detailed records of all expenses
- • Consider self-representation for smaller claims
During Litigation
- • Make reasonable settlement offers
- • Follow the 7-day rule for offers
- • Keep offers open until trial
- • Document all disbursements with receipts
Settlement Strategy
- • Consider the other party's likely costs
- • Factor in the risk of double-costs
- • Make offers that account for legal fees
- • Don't reject offers out of spite
Cost Management
- • Understand your maximum cost exposure
- • Keep service costs under $60/person
- • Limit preparation costs to $200
- • Act reasonably throughout the process
Conclusion
Ontario's Small Claims Court cost rules represent a careful balance between access to justice, proportionality, and fairness. The 15% cap ensures that legal costs don't overwhelm small disputes, while exceptions for settlement offers and unreasonable behavior maintain incentives for good faith litigation.
Understanding these rules helps you make informed decisions about litigation, settlement, and legal representation. Whether you're considering a claim or defending one, knowing your potential cost exposure and recovery rights is essential for effective legal strategy.
Ready to Calculate?
Use our calculator to estimate cost awards for your specific situation, applying all the rules and caps discussed in this guide.
Use the Calculator